Promiscuous binding of different Janus kinases (JAKs) to class I/II cytokine receptors has been reported, yet its role in signaling is unclear. To systematically explore JAK pairing in type I interferon (IFN-I) signaling, we generated an artificial IFN-I receptor (AIR) by replacing the extracellular domains of IFNAR1 and IFNAR2 with anti mEGFP and mCherry nanobodies. The heterodimeric AIR restored near-native IFN-I activity, while the homomeric variant of IFNAR2 (AIR-dR2) initiated much weaker signaling despite harboring docking sites for signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT) proteins. AIR-dR1 was signaling inactive, yet, pulldown uncovered its ICD to bind both TYK2 and JAK1. To further investigate the roles of JAKs on the receptors, knockout (KO) JAK1, JAK2, TYK2, and JAK2/TYK2 were generated. JAK1 KO led to complete loss of IFN-I signaling, which was partially restored by TYK2 overexpression. TYK2 KO cells retained partial activity, which was elevated by JAK1 overexpression, suggesting both JAKs to partially substitute each other. Conversely, JAK2 KO only moderately impacted the biological activity of IFN-Is, even in JAK2/TYK2 KO cells. Live cell micropatterning confirmed promiscuous binding of JAK1, JAK2 and TYK2 to IFNAR1 and IFNAR2, in line with an AlphaFold model that shows JAKs interchangeability on IFNAR ICDs. Similar promiscuity of JAK binding was observed for TPOR and GHR but not EPOR, accompanied by different downstream signaling activity. The competitive binding of JAKs to cytokine receptors together with the highly diverse absolute and relative JAK expression levels can account for cell typedependent signaling pleiotropy observed for cytokine receptors.