Plasmodium falciparum RH5 is the most advanced blood-stage malaria vaccine candidate and is under evaluation for efficacy in endemic regions, emphasizing the need to study the underlying antibody response to RH5 during natural infection. Here, we found that RH5-reactive B cells were rare in malaria-exposed individuals despite repeated infections over multiple years. RH5-specific monoclonal antibodies isolated from these individuals were extensively mutated but mostly targeted non-neutralizing epitopes, in contrast to antibodies from RH5-vaccinated, malaria-naive individuals. However, infection-derived MAD8-151 and MAD8-502 were among the most potent neutralizers out of 186 antibodies isolated from both cohorts and target the same epitopes as the most effective vaccine-induced antibodies. Binding to basigin receptor-proximal epitopes was the primary factor governing the potency of RH5-specific antibodies from both natural infection and vaccination, followed by the strength of binding. These results indicate a clear strategy for the development of next-generation RH5 vaccines for use in malaria-endemic regions.

Natural malaria infection elicits rare but potent neutralizing antibodies to the blood-stage antigen RH5