Abstract

The majority of genetic variants associated with complex human autoimmune diseases reside in enhancers1-3, non-coding regulatory elements that control gene expression. In contrast with variants that directly alter protein-coding sequences, enhancer variants are predicted to tune gene expression modestly and function in specific cellular contexts4, suggesting that small alterations in the functions of key immune cell populations are sufficient to shape disease risk. Here we tested this concept by experimentally perturbing distinct enhancers governing the high affinity IL-2 receptor alpha chain (IL2RA; also known as CD25). IL2RA is an immune regulator that promotes the pro- and anti-inflammatory functions of conventional T cells (Tconvs) and regulatory T cells (Tregs), respectively, and non-coding genetic variants in IL2RA have been linked to multiple autoimmune disorders4. We previously tiled across the IL2RA locus using CRISPR-activation and identified a stimulation-responsive element (CaRE4) with an enhancer that modestly affects the kinetics of IL2RA expression in Tconvs5. This enhancer is conserved across species and harbors a common human SNP associated with protection from Type 1 Diabetes (T1D)5,6. We now identified an additional conserved enhancer, termed CaRE3 enhancer, which modestly affected steady state IL2RA expression in regulatory T cells (Tregs). Despite their seemingly subtle impact on gene expression, the CaRE3 and CaRE4 enhancers had pronounced yet divergent effects on the incidence of diabetes in autoimmune prone animals. Deletion of the conserved CaRE4 enhancer completely protected against autoimmune diabetes even in animals treated with an immunostimulating anti-PD1 checkpoint inhibitor, whereas deletion of the CaRE3 enhancer accelerated spontaneous disease progression. Quantitative multiplexed imaging of the pancreatic lymph nodes (panLNs) revealed that each enhancer deletion preferentially affected the protein expression levels of IL2RA in activated Tconvs or Tregs, reciprocally tuning local competition for IL-2 input signals. In animals lacking the CaRE4 enhancer, skewed IL-2 signaling favored Tregs, increasing their local density around activated Tconvs to strongly suppress emergence of autoimmune effectors. By contrast, in animals lacking the CaRE3 enhancer, IL-2 signals were skewed towards activated Tconvs, promoting their escape from Treg control. Collectively, this work illustrates how subtle changes in gene regulation due to non-coding variation can significantly alter disease progression and how distinct enhancers controlling the same gene can have opposing effects on disease outcomes through cell type-selective activity.