Abstract Neoantigens derived from somatic mutations have been demonstrated to correlate with therapeutic responses mediated by treatment with immune checkpoint inhibitors. Neoantigens are therefore highly attractive targets for the development of personalized medicine approaches although their quality and associated immune responses is not yet well understood. In a case study of metastatic malignant melanoma, we performed an in-depth characterization of neoantigens and respective T-cell responses in the context of immunotherapy with Ipilimumab. Three neoantigens identified either by immunopeptidomics or in silico prediction were investigated using binding affinity analyses and structural simulations. We isolated seven T-cell receptors (TCRs) from the patient immune repertoire recognizing these antigens. TCRs were compared in-vitro and in-vivo with multi-parametric analyses. Identified immunogenic peptides showed similar binding affinities to the human leukocyte antigen (HLA) complex and comparable differences to their wildtype counterparts in molecular dynamic simulations. Nevertheless, isolated TCRs differed substantially in functionality and frequency. In fact, TCRs with comparably lower functional avidity and higher potential for cross-reactivity provided at least equal anti-tumor immune responses in vivo. Of note, these TCRs showed a reduced activation pattern upon primary in vitro stimulation. Exploration of the TCR-β repertoire in blood and in different tumor-related tissues over three years, offered insights on the high frequency and particular long-term persistence of low-avidity TCRs. These data indicate that qualitative differences of neoantigen-specific TCRs and their impact on function and longevity need to be considered for neoantigen targeting by adoptive T-cell therapy using TCR-transgenic T cells. Statement of translational relevance Immunotherapy has demonstrated high efficacy in diverse malignancies. Neoantigens derived from mutations provide promising targets for safe and highly tumor-specific therapeutic approaches. Yet, single determinants of an effective and enduring T-cell mediated tumor rejection are still not well understood. We analyzed in detail seven neoantigen-specific T-cell receptors (TCRs) derived from a melanoma patient targeting three different altered peptide ligands identified by mass spectrometry and prediction analyses. Functional characterization of these TCRs revealed potent anti-tumor reactivity of all TCRs. Of special interest, TCRs with comparably lower affinity demonstrated effective in vivo activity as well as dominant spatial and temporal distribution in blood and tissue. Functional differences of TCR may require further T-cell and/or TCR engineering and should be considered for future clinical trial designs.

Spatial and temporal plasticity of neoantigen-specific T-cell responses bases on characteristics associated to antigen and TCR