Abstract

The gut microbiome is complex, raising questions about the role of individual strains in the community. Here, we address this question by focusing on a functional unit within the community, the metabolic niche that controls bile acid 7-dehydroxylation. By constructing variants of a complex defined community in which we drop out strains that occupy this niche, we explore how interactions within and between niches shape community-level metabolism. Omitting both members of the niche, Clostridium scindens (Cs) and Clostridium hylemonae (Ch), eliminates secondary bile acid production and reshapes the community in a highly specific manner: eight strains go up or down in relative abundance by >100-fold, while the remaining strains are largely unaffected. In single-strain dropout communities (i.e., a strain swap within the niche), Cs and Ch reach the same relative abundance and dehydroxylate bile acids to a similar extent. However, the effect on strains in other niches differs markedly: Clostridium sporogenes increases >1000-fold in the {Delta}Cs but not {Delta}Ch dropout, reshaping the pool of microbiome-derived phenylalanine metabolites. Thus, strains that are functionally redundant within a niche can have widely varying impacts outside the niche, and a strain swap can ripple through the community in an unpredictable manner, resulting in a large impact on an unrelated community-level phenotype. Mice colonized by the {Delta}Cs{Delta}Ch community show decreased liver steatosis relative to those colonized by the {Delta}Ch community, demonstrating that a single strain from the microbiome can have a substantive impact on host physiology. Our work opens the door to the mechanistic studies of the role of an individual strain on community ecology and host physiology.