Paper
Document
Submit new version
Download
Flag content
1

Histogram of oriented gradients: a technique for the study of molecular cloud formation

Authors
J. D. Soler,H. Beuther
M. Rugel,Y. Wang,P. C. Clark,S. C. O. Glover,P. F. Goldsmith,M. Heyer,L. D. Anderson,A. Goodman,Th. Henning,J. Kainulainen,R. S. Klessen,S. N. Longmore,N. M. McClure-Griffiths,K. M. Menten,J. C. Mottram,J. Ott,S. E. Ragan,R. J. Smith,J. S. Urquhart,F. Bigiel,P. Hennebelle,N. Roy,P. Schilke,J. Soler,Paul Clark,Simon Glover,Paul Goldsmith,L. Anderson,Alyssa Goodman,Ralf Klessen,S. Longmore,N. McClure-Griffiths,K. Menten,J. Mottram,S. Ragan,Rowan Smith,J. Urquhart,Frank Bigiel
+38 authors
,Nirupam Roy
Published
Feb 1, 2019
Show more
Save
TipTip
Document
Submit new version
Download
Flag content
1
TipTip
Save
Document
Submit new version
Download
Flag content
Overall Assessment


Add review category
Introduction
Does the introduction clearly articulate the research question and provide adequate context? Is the study's significance within the field convincingly established?
Methods
Does the study design test the authors' hypothesis? Are the methods described in enough detail for independent replication?
Results
Were the study's findings analyzed and interpreted reasonably? Is the resulting data open and auditable? Are the figures of high resolution, describe data appropriately and adequately labelled? Please provide comments - positive or negative on each figure including supplementary ones.
Discussion
Do the results support the authors’ conclusions? Are there any alternative interpretations of the study's findings that the authors should have considered?
Best
Best
Newest
Upvoted
This paper has not been reviewed yet.