The novel properties of the faint supernova SN 2005E mean that it does not fit readily into the established supernova categories. Types Ib, Ic and II, core-collapse supernovae, are thought to form when a massive star explodes at the end of its life, and type Ia as a result of the thermonuclear explosion of an accreting white dwarf. From spectroscopic data, Perets et al. conclude that SN 2005E is helium rich, like a type Ib, and lacks the hydrogen, silicon and sulphur spectral lines typical of type Ia. But based on its presence in an 'old' stellar environment, and with a low derived ejected mass, they argue against a core-collapse origin and for an origin from a low-mass, old progenitor, probably a helium-accreting white dwarf in a binary system. Kawabata et al. see it differently. SN 2005E resembles SN 2005cz, they say, a type Ib supernova that is unusual in being found in an elliptical galaxy. Both SN 2005E and SN 2005cz, they suggest, are best explained as products of the core collapse of massive stars at the low (6–12 solar mass) end of massiveness. In the accompanying News & Views, David Branch discusses these two models in the context of the latest thinking on how stars explode. Supernovae are thought to arise through one of two processes. Type Ib/c and type II supernovae are produced when the cores of massive, short-lived stars undergo gravitational core collapse and eject a few solar masses. Type Ia supernovae are thought to form by the thermonuclear detonation of a carbon-oxygen white dwarf. Here a faint type Ib supernova, SN 2005E, is reported that seems not to have had a core-collapse origin, but perhaps arose from a low-mass, old progenitor, probably a helium-accreting white dwarf in a binary. Supernovae are thought to arise from two different physical processes. The cores of massive, short-lived stars undergo gravitational core collapse and typically eject a few solar masses during their explosion. These are thought to appear as type Ib/c and type II supernovae, and are associated with young stellar populations. In contrast, the thermonuclear detonation of a carbon-oxygen white dwarf, whose mass approaches the Chandrasekhar limit, is thought to produce type Ia supernovae1,2. Such supernovae are observed in both young and old stellar environments. Here we report a faint type Ib supernova, SN 2005E, in the halo of the nearby isolated galaxy, NGC 1032. The ‘old’ environment near the supernova location, and the very low derived ejected mass (∼0.3 solar masses), argue strongly against a core-collapse origin. Spectroscopic observations and analysis reveal high ejecta velocities, dominated by helium-burning products, probably excluding this as a subluminous3,4 or a regular1 type Ia supernova. We conclude that it arises from a low-mass, old progenitor, likely to have been a helium-accreting white dwarf in a binary. The ejecta contain more calcium than observed in other types of supernovae and probably large amounts of radioactive 44Ti.

A faint type of supernova from a white dwarf with a helium-rich companion