Distributed coastal/offshore seawater splitting plants can facilitate H2-based economy's global deployment. Increasingly, studies emerge mostly focusing on inhibiting anodic oxidation of halide ions. Equally tricky cathodic precipitation in natural seawater reduction (NSR) is neglected due to the use of alkaline seawater in most studies. Herein, we explore possible strategies (introducing a proton sponge to change cathodic microenvironments, breaking local OH− gradients, employing self-cleaning cathodes) to alleviate surface precipitation. We introduce a famous H2 evolution-active metal, Pt, onto a self-cleaning carbon support with H2 gas evacuation capability. Our proposed binder-free Pt/carbon cathode is more robust than many previous Pt/C cathodes for NSR. Moreover, we highlight possibilities of co-electrosynthesizing nano-sized Mg hydroxides and H2 from natural seawater. This work suggests that designs of local environments, pH gradient disruption, and/or cathode architecture-based gas/liquid flows may suppress surface precipitation. We demonstrate in detail the various issues in NSR and possible solutions.