Background: There are over 200 published species within the Lactobacillus Genus Complex (LGC), the majority of which have sequenced type strain genomes available. Although gold standard, genome-based species delimitation cutoffs are accepted by the community, they are seldom checked against currently available genome data. In addition, there are many species-level misclassification issues within the LGC. We constructed a de novo species taxonomy for the LGC based on 2,459 publicly available, decent-quality genomes and using a 94% core nucleotide identity threshold. We reconciled these de novo species with published species and subspecies names by (i) identifying genomes of type strains in our dataset and (ii) performing comparisons based on 16S rRNA sequence identity against type strains. Results: We found that genomes within the LGC could be divided into 239 clusters (de novo species) that were discontinuous and exclusive. Comparison of these de novo species to published species lead to the identification of ten sets of published species that can be merged and one species that can be split. Further, we found at least eight genome clusters that constitute new species. Finally, we were able to accurately classify 98 unclassified genomes and reclassify 74 wrongly classified genomes. Conclusions: The current state of LGC species taxonomy is largely consistent with genome data, but there are some inconsistencies as well as genome misclassifications. These inconsistencies should be resolved to evolve towards a meaningful taxonomy where species have a consistent size in terms of sequence divergence.

A genome-based species taxonomy of the Lactobacillus Genus Complex