Brain abscess is a devastating illness, with a high risk of morbidity and mortality. Recurrent brain abscess poses a challenge to diagnosis while treatment options may differ. Right to left shunt is a lesser-explored etiology for recurrent brain abscesses. PubMed literature review was performed to study all published studies with reference to right to left cardiac shunt as a possible etiology for the recurrent brain abscesses. The authors also report a case of a young male who developed recurrent brain abscess after previous resection and treatment. Right to left cardiac shunting of deoxygenated blood is an etiology for recurrent brain abscess formation. Thorough systemic workup and multispecialty treatment is recommended to treat this relatively uncommon presentation.