Abstract Plasmodium vivax , one species parasite causing human malaria, forms a dormant liver stage, termed the hypnozoite, which activate weeks, months or years after the primary infection, causing relapse episodes. Relapses significantly contribute to the vivax malaria burden and are only killed with drugs of the 8-aminoquinolone class, which are contraindicated in many vulnerable populations. Development of new therapies targeting hypnozoites is hindered, in part, by the lack of robust methods to continuously culture and characterize this parasite. As a result, the determinants of relapse periodicity and the molecular processes that drive hypnozoite formation, persistence, and activation are largely unknown. While previous reports have described vastly different liver stage growth metrics attributable to which hepatocyte donor lot is used to initiate culture, a comprehensive assessment of how different P. vivax patient isolates behave in the same donors at the same time is logistically challenging. Using our primary human hepatocyte-based P. vivax liver stage culture platform, we aimed to simultaneously test the effects of how hepatocyte donor and P. vivax patient isolate influence the fate of sporozoites and growth of liver schizonts. We found that, while environmental factors such as hepatocyte donor can modulate hypnozoite formation rate, the P. vivax case is also an important determinant of the proportion of hypnozoites observed in culture. In addition, we found schizont growth to be mostly influenced by hepatocyte donor. These results suggest that, while host hepatocytes harbor characteristics making them more-or less-supportive of a quiescent versus growing intracellular parasite, sporozoite fating towards hypnozoites is isolate-specific. Future studies involving these host-parasite interactions, including characterization of individual P. vivax strains, should consider the impact of culture conditions on hypnozoite formation, in order to better understand this important part of the parasite’s lifecycle. Author summary Malaria is caused by protozoan parasites of the genus Plasmodium . One species, Plasmodium vivax , is more difficult to control in comparison to other species because infection results in dormant forms in the liver, called hypnozoites. Hypnozoites are considered an invaluable therapeutic target to control malaria, but how hypnozoites form and reactive to cause malaria relapses is unknown. Herein we describe that both nature and nurture influence the fate of newly-established parasites in the liver, resulting in either a quiescent hypnozoite or growing schizont. Using parasites generated from patient isolates, we show the hypnozoite formation is likely inherited but also modulated by environmental factors, including which lot of human hepatocytes the parasites infect. Additionally, we show schizont growth is strongly influenced by the host hepatocyte lot. As liver stage experiments include several dependent variables which are difficult to control, herein we present an experimental approach designed to remove many of these variables and provide a clearer picture of what factors influence the formation and growth of liver stage parasites. Our findings serve as a foundation for future work to understand hypnozoite biology, with the ultimate goal of identifying new therapeutic targets.