Abstract According to the principles of heredity, each parental allele of hybrids equally participates in the progeny. At some loci, however, it happens that one allele is favored to the expense of the other. Gamete killers are genetic systems where one allele (the killer) triggers the death of the gametes carrying the other (killed) allele. They have been found in many organisms, and are of major interest to understand mechanisms of evolution and speciation. Gamete killers are particularly prevalent in plants, where they can compromise crop breeding. Here, we deciphered a pollen killer in Arabidopsis thaliana by exploiting natural variation, de novo genomic sequencing and mutants, and analyzing segregations in crosses. We found that the killer allele carries an antidote gene flanked by two elements mandatory for the killing activity. We identified the gene encoding the antidote, a chimeric protein addressed to mitochondria. This gene appeared in the species by association of domains recruited from other genes, and it recently underwent duplications within a highly variable locus, particularly in the killer genotypes. Exploring the species diversity, we identified sequence polymorphisms correlated with the antidote activity.