Abstract Silybum marianum is used to protect against degenerative liver damage. The molecular mechanisms of its bioactive component, silybin, remained enigmatic, although membrane-stabilizing properties, modulation of membrane protein function, and metabolic regulation have been discussed for decades. Here, we show that specifically the stereoisomer silybin A decreases triglyceride levels and lipid droplet content, while enriching major phospholipid classes and maintaining a homeostatic phospholipid composition in human hepatocytes in vitro and in mouse liver in vivo under normal and pre-disease conditions. Conversely, in cell-based disease models of lipid overload and lipotoxic stress, silybin treatment primarily depletes triglycerides. Mechanistically, silymarin/silybin suppresses phospholipid-degrading enzymes, induces phospholipid biosynthesis to varying degrees depending on the conditions, and down-regulates triglyceride biosynthesis, while inducing complex changes in sterol and fatty acid metabolism. Structure-activity relationship studies highlight the importance of the 1,4-benzodioxane ring configuration of silybin A in triglyceride reduction and the saturated 2,3-bond of the flavanonol moiety in phospholipid accumulation. Enrichment of hepatic phospholipids and intracellular membrane expansion are associated with an heightened biotransformation capacity. In conclusion, our study deciphers the structural features of silybin contributing to hepatic lipid reorganization and offers insights into its liver-protective mechanism, potentially involving a context-dependent lipid class switch from triglycerides to phospholipids.