Abstract α-Synuclein aggregation is a key driver of neurodegeneration in Parkinson’s disease and related syndromes. Accordingly, obtaining a molecule that targets α-synuclein pathogenic assemblies with high affinity and selectivity is a long-pursued objective. Here, we have exploited the biophysical properties of toxic oligomers and amyloid fibrils to identify a family of α-helical peptides that bind selectively to these α-synuclein species with low nanomolar affinity, without interfering with the monomeric functional protein. This activity is translated into an unprecedented anti-aggregation potency and the ability to abrogate the oligomers toxicity. With a structure-function relationship in hand, we identified a human peptide expressed in the brain and in the gastrointestinal tract with exceptional binding, antiaggregation, and detoxifying properties, which suggests it might play a protective role against synucleinopathies. The chemical entities we describe here represent a new therapeutic paradigm and are promising tools to assist diagnosis by selectively detecting α-synuclein pathogenic species in biofluids.