Abstract While the past decade has seen meaningful improvements in clinical outcomes for multiple myeloma patients, a subset of patients do not benefit from current therapeutics for unclear reasons. Many gene expression-based models of risk have been developed, but each model uses a different combination of genes and often involve assaying many genes making them difficult to implement. We organized the Multiple Myeloma DREAM Challenge, a crowdsourced effort to develop models of rapid progression in newly diagnosed myeloma patients and to benchmark these against previously published models. This effort lead to more robust predictors and found that incorporating specific demographic and clinical features improved gene expression-based models of high risk. Furthermore, post challenge analysis identified a novel expression-based risk marker and histone modifier, PHF19 , which featured prominently in several independent models. Lastly, we show that a simple four feature predictor composed of age, International Staging System stage (ISS), and expression of PHF19 and MMSET performs similarly to more complex models with many more gene expression features included. Key points Most comprehensive and unbiased assessment of prognostic biomarkers in MM resulting in a robust and parsimonious model. Identification of PHF19 as the expression based biomarker most strongly associated with rapid progression in MM patients.