Hypoactive BRAF mutants bind more tightly than wild type to the upstream regulator RAS, thus amplifying to amplify ERK signalling; tumours expressing these mutants require coexistent mechanisms for RAS activation to grow and are sensitive to their inhibition. Mutant alleles of the kinase BRAF have been identified in human tumours, some of which have activated catalytic functions, whereas others have impaired or absent kinase activity. Here Neal Rosen and colleagues have characterized the less-understood hypoactive BRAF mutants. They find that these mutants bind more tightly to the upstream regulator RAS in order to amplify signalling and require coexistent mechanisms for RAS activation in the tumour in order to function. The mechanistic action of these hypoactive BRAF mutants is different to that of the activated mutants and dictates their sensitivity to therapeutic inhibitors of the pathway. Elsewhere in this issue, David Santamaria and colleagues show that kinase-inactive BRAF mutants can initiate the development of lung adenocarcinoma in mice. Approximately 200 BRAF mutant alleles have been identified in human tumours. Activating BRAF mutants cause feedback inhibition of GTP-bound RAS, are RAS-independent and signal either as active monomers (class 1) or constitutively active dimers (class 2)1. Here we characterize a third class of BRAF mutants—those that have impaired kinase activity or are kinase-dead. These mutants are sensitive to ERK-mediated feedback and their activation of signalling is RAS-dependent. The mutants bind more tightly than wild-type BRAF to RAS–GTP, and their binding to and activation of wild-type CRAF is enhanced, leading to increased ERK signalling. The model suggests that dysregulation of signalling by these mutants in tumours requires coexistent mechanisms for maintaining RAS activation despite ERK-dependent feedback. Consistent with this hypothesis, melanomas with these class 3 BRAF mutations also harbour RAS mutations or NF1 deletions. By contrast, in lung and colorectal cancers with class 3 BRAF mutants, RAS is typically activated by receptor tyrosine kinase signalling. These tumours are sensitive to the inhibition of RAS activation by inhibitors of receptor tyrosine kinases. We have thus defined three distinct functional classes of BRAF mutants in human tumours. The mutants activate ERK signalling by different mechanisms that dictate their sensitivity to therapeutic inhibitors of the pathway.

Tumours with class 3 BRAF mutants are sensitive to the inhibition of activated RAS